Mangia Bene Big Slice

"Not like it used to be. Enjoyed them for years before we moved out of the area. Decided them post remodel, super disappointed. Based on recent reviews, maybe it was just an off day? Idk. Calzone was FLAT, and I mean FLAT with barely any filling (see pics). Flavor was ok, but not worth the $21+ . Also ordered a Greek salad - the dressing was thin/ soupy , Like someone half filled the cup with water. Called to inquire and the only explanation was a dry “yeah..we make it here” response. Beyond disappointed."

"We’ve been to Big Slice (Mangia Bene) four times now, and every single visit has been amazing! The original pepperoni is our go-to, but honestly, all of their specialty slices are just as delicious. The owner is incredibly kind, and Kelly Ann is the sweetest-she makes the whole experience even better. We 100% recommend this pizzeria. If you’re in the area, it’s a must-try!"

"Go-to pizza spot in Cape hands down! The Brooklyn square and the truffle mushroom slices are INSANE. Don't even get me started on the cheese steak. AND they have a coffee bar! Anthony and his family are the real deal and more importantly, very kind and loving people!! Def a new favorite of mine, already saved it on my maps"

"The remodel is beautiful and really gives you that classic NY pizza shop feel. I love that you can get pizza by the slice, and it’s not floppy or dripping grease! Anthony was very friendly & even introduced us to Mom! 10/10 would recommend!"